Well, that was fun, wasn’t it? Last week in this space I thought Coastal would blow the doors off of Liberty if they met on the field. Turns out, through a COVID outbreak at Liberty, BYU was easily slid in as an opponent. It was a crazy 48 hours to get to a historic matchup, and that game was the headliner of a week that really shuffled the deck on the G5 list. Let’s dive into the action.
18 Stripes G5 Top 10 Poll
RANK | TEAM | RECORD | LAST WEEK |
---|---|---|---|
1 | Cincinnati | 8-0 | BYE |
2 | Coastal Carolina (+1) | 10-0 | 22-17 Win vs BYU |
3 | BYU (-1) | 9-1 | 22-17 Loss @ Coastal Carolina |
4 | Louisiana (+1) | 9-1 | 24-21 Win @ Appalachian State |
5 | Buffalo (+1) | 4-0 | Canceled @ Ohio |
6 | Tulsa (+1) | 6-1 | 19-6 Win @ Navy |
7 | Marshall (-3) | 7-1 | 20-0 Loss vs Rice |
8 | San Jose State (NR) | 5-0 | 35-24 Win vs Hawaii |
9 | Boise State | 3-1 | Canceled @ UNLV |
10 | Nevada (NR) | 6-1 | 37-26 Win vs Fresno State |
Also Considered: Liberty, Army, Western Michigan, SMU, Memphis, UCF, Appalachian State, Ball State
(Yes I considered all of those teams)
Week 14 Recap
As mentioned above, the game of the weekend took place in Conway, SC changed on the fly over the course of 48 hours. College Gameday made the trip, despite the game being on ESPNU when the game was originally Coastal vs Liberty. The game itself was intense, as noted at the halftime scuffle after BYU Zach Wilson was roughed up by two Coastal defenders as Wilson’s Hail Mary attempt was intercepted by the Chanticleers. Wilson had a pedestrian day by his standards, as he finished with 240 yards and a sole TD, and the aforementioned INT at the end of the first half. The Coastal D-Line came to play and made things uncomfortable with five hurries and a sack on Wilson. Coastal Carolina came out with a gameplan to control the clock. Their two first down touchdown drives almost spanned 15 total minutes. A big part of that control was the rushing attack shared by RBs CJ Marable (132 Yds 2 TDs) and Reese White (53 yards 1 TD) and QB Grayson McCall (68 Yds). Despite this potent rushing attack, Coastal declined to go for it on 4th and 1 to put the game away. Instead, we got a one minute drill for Wilson and the Cougars that finished with an ending reminiscent of Super Bowl XXXIV, and put Coastal to 10-0 and striking down the brief hopes for BYU’s CFP and NY6 bowl hopes.
In the other major matchup of the weekend, App State and Louisiana had one of the weirdest couple of hours to behold. Louisiana trailed at halftime 10-9, after both teams combined for two turnovers, two drives ending in downs (due to high snaps on punts but we’ll get back to that), a missed FG, and a missed extra point. The third quarter belonged to the Raging Cajuns, as they turned an opening drive interception into a TD and 2 point conversion, and then forced a quick three and out before marching down the field for another score to go up 24-10. The Mountaineers then responded, as the rain started to pour in Boone, making it 24-17. This is where things go a little sideways. UL goes three and out, and the long snapper, having already shown his struggles snapping, put the snap over the punter’s head which led to a safety. App State got the ball back now with a chance to go ahead and got stonewalled once they got relatively deep into Ragin Cajun territory. UL responds to this drive by trying to force App State to use its timeouts, which they do. On 4th down Billy Napier decides that instead of having his punting team potentially give up a safety or TD he sends his offense out to run backwards 35 yards to take the safety themselves to make it a 3 point lead for the away team. App State returns that favor by driving down the field with a chance to tie, that they go and shank to give UL a weird Friday night result.
App State and BYU were only two of five that were in last week’s Top 15 (Top 10+Others Considered). Plus if you take out the six teams that were on bye or had their games cancelled that percentage goes way up and put this list in flux, as I mentioned Saturday night. The first upset is the one that is most shocking. Marshall got shut out for the first time since 2000 in a home defeat to Rice. Rice was playing in just their fourth game of the season after starting late. Grant Wells struggled for Marshall, throwing a career high 5 interceptions, the final one being taken back for a TD to put the game out of reach for the Herd. Marshall still sits in the driver seat for C-USA, but time will tell if they maintain that grip. Memphis, who had seemingly turned a corner after their defeat to Cincinnati, was throttled by Tulane, led by their QB Michael Pratt, who threw 2 TDs and added two more on the ground. Memphis fell behind early in the second half after turning the ball over on downs and allowing the Wave to go up two scores on the ensuing drive. The Tigers defense struggled mightily getting off the field, allowing Tulane to go 3-3 on fourth downs. In the MAC, Western Michigan got punched in the mouth by Eastern Michigan, who clearly recovered from their near win from a week prior. Two fumbles in the third quarter turned a two point game into a fifteen point game and Western could not recover and get their first loss of the short season.
Waiting for the Broncos next week will be the blazing Ball State Cardinals. The boys from Muncie (shout out Garry Gergich and his timeshare) took care of business against Central Michigan 45-20. The Cardinals were led by their Senior QB Drew Plitt who accounts for five TDs on the day (four through the air and one on the ground). The Cardinals now control their own destiny in the MAC after falling in their first game to Miami (OH). The reason they do hold their fate in their hands is because Miami (OH) was one of two key cancellations this week as their game against Kent State was cancelled due to an outbreak. Also notable, Buffalo’s contest with Ohio and due to their historic win a week ago against Kent State, essentially clinches the MAC East with their game against Akron still to go.
The Mountain West finally got the clarity I had been looking for the past couple of weeks. First, on the island (due to Santa Clara County’s restrictions) San Jose State continued their unbeaten start by using a hot start vs Hawaii and hold on 35-24, putting themselves in the driver’s seat for a Mountain West Championship Game appearance. The teams standing in their way are Boise State, who had yet another game canceled this week, and Nevada. The Wolfpack bounced back from their poor trip to Hawaii by taking on Fresno State late Saturday night, winning 37-26. Nevada overcame some miscues on the offensive side of the ball to keep Fresno State at bay. An 85 yard TD pitch and catch to Tory Horton (one of his three TD grabs on the night) put the Bulldogs away for good.
In wrap-around to finish up the week, Tulsa used their defense to keep Navy’s triple option at bay winning 16-6, heading into their double header with Cincinnati. On Thursday night, Louisiana Tech kept their slim C-USA Title hopes alive with a win over North Texas 42-31, their first game since Halloween. Georgia Southern smothered Florida Atlantic (who is still alive in the C-USA Championship themselves), winning 20-3.
Week 15 Games to Watch
Cincinnati (-14) at Tulsa
The first of two guaranteed matchups, the pressure appears to be entirely on Cincinnati, and their faint CFP hopes. (Reminder I write these before the CFP Rankings come out). I imagine Tulsa will want to win since it’s in their own building and can guarantee another game in their building with a win, but I can’t imagine them emptying the playbook in this game knowing that no matter what they will see Cincinnati next weekend.
Navy at Army (-4)
It is Army-Navy week!! One of my favorite times of the year is to set up my Christmas decorations and watch Army vs Navy in a cold weather environment in a giant NFL stadium. While that won’t happen this year, with the game at West Point (and my Christmas decorations already up) I imagine there will be some pageantry to follow this game. It will be interesting to see if the rest of the CFB world follows this game now that it’s not the sole game of the weekend. It should be a great showcase for Army on a national level.
Nevada at San Jose State (-5)
A defacto Mountain West semifinal, one of these teams will come out of this game playing Boise State (presumably on the Smurf Turf) two weekends from now. Both teams have shown propensity to not play to their fullest potential, but I’ve seen it more out of San Jose State, so I think the Spartans will continue their incredible season (Rank San Jose State AP voters!). Also worth noting that this game will be played in Las Vegas due to the aforementioned restrictions.
Western Michigan at Ball State (-2)
Another defacto semifinal, this time in the MAC. Buffalo awaits either of these teams battling in Muncie. Ball State has the hot streak and the Vegas crowd behind them, but advanced numbers seem to still be behind the Broncos. I imagine that this time next week, this will be one of the top games of the weekend as I expect it to be close throughout the game.
San Diego State at BYU (-14)/Coastal Carolina (-15) at Troy
I wanted to end with these games because both of them are coming off emotional highs/lows, depending on your perspective, and could be setup for a letdown. San Diego State’s strengths are in their defense and could potentially slow down this slowed down offense in BYU. Troy also has been feisty with some of their fellow Sun Belt compadres, and with Coastal Carolina knocking on the door of a Top 10 ranking, and a Sun Belt showdown the following week with Louisiana, all I’m saying is be careful out there.
Assuming double-digit favorites UC and CCU both win this weekend the AAC and Sun Belt should agree to let UC and CCU play the 19th to create the worlds most convincing case for why a G5 team should make the playoff (only for the winner to be left out of the playoff).
That would be fun. Only issue, like you say, is they still would get left out. Could you see Coastal beating A&M or Florida? I couldn’t. The big power house teams are main hurdle for them, not each other. And those P5 teams are likely to get left out, barring something crazy.
I do hope these teams get the chance for NY6 representation though. There’s no rule that says a maximum of 1 G5 team can make it. Would be pretty cool to see two.
Yeah but if two make it it’s for certain the committee will have them playing each other, ugh! Just to spoil it and protect the big boys…
Just a heads up if it hasn’t been mentioned elsewhere:
https://www.gofundme.com/f/rakes-report-christmas-giving-2020
Already raised $4,500 from the initial goal of $2,847
We were giggling over the weekend about Coastal’s center Sam Thompson:
5’9″ 290 pounds and he can really scoot!