About Andy Roberts

A lifelong subway alum, Andy specializes in instant reactions to Notre Dame games.

On to the Next One: College Football Playoff Round 1 Instant Reaction

All week, I couldn't shake the thought that Notre Dame was going to win comfortably over Indiana. (And they did. 27-17, final score, and it wasn't that close.) It's not the Hoosiers' fault. The idea some will probably start trumpeting that IU didn't belong in this playoff because their schedule was too weak was, in [...]

By |2024-12-21T02:32:02-05:00December 21st, 2024|18S Reads|7 Comments

Looking Ahead: Notre Dame Seeded #7, to Face Indiana in 1st Round of Playoff

Notre Dame fans entered the weekend with stars in their eyes and visions of the coveted #5 seed in the College Football Playoff. Just about nothing that had to happen for that to transpire took place, and instead the Irish were seeded #7 (with a true rank of #5 by the committee) and matched up [...]

By |2024-12-08T18:59:51-05:00December 8th, 2024|18S Reads|30 Comments

The Four Horsemen Are Back: Army Instant Reaction

It was yet another day where the biggest issue Notre Dame fans faced was annoyance at a garbage time touchdown by the other team, and the Irish walloped previously unbeaten Army 49-14 to move one win away from hosting a playoff game. Pretty much everything was hitting on all cylinders for the Irish, except for [...]

By |2024-11-24T00:21:20-05:00November 24th, 2024|18S Reads, Football|10 Comments

Your Flag Means Death: Virginia Instant Reaction

I don't know if I've ever seen a team ignited by a flag before, but that's what happened Saturday as an arcane rules interpretation screwed up the coolest fake punt of all time and pissed Notre Dame off enough to finish delivering a 3-touchdown second-quarter rage bomb in a 35-14 win over Virginia. First up, [...]

By |2024-11-16T19:45:29-05:00November 16th, 2024|18S Reads, Football|20 Comments

Doing the Job: Florida State Instant Reaction

When you're playing a team as utterly hapless as Florida State, you just want to make sure they have no reason to care. Notre Dame did not Saturday night, dispatching the Seminoles 52-3 and moving a step closer to a College Football Playoff spot. The defense threw a sack party in the Florida State backfield, [...]

By |2024-11-10T00:02:04-05:00November 10th, 2024|18S Reads|17 Comments

Playoff Predictor: Georgia Tech Instant Reaction

Before you read this reaction post, remember to let me know in the comments how you think my writing affected Notre Dame's College Football Playoff chances. You might as well, as almost literally every other thing that happened during Saturday's 31-13 win over Georgia Tech was examined through that lens, as opposed to being concerned [...]

By |2024-10-19T22:17:23-04:00October 19th, 2024|18S Reads, Football|24 Comments

A Complete Game: Stanford Instant Reaction

For a little while Saturday, it looked like Stanford was hitting all the checkpoints for an annoyingly stupid Notre Dame game against a lesser opponent that went down to the wire. Not this time, though. Notre Dame exploded for 49 straight points after an opening Cardinal touchdown drive and cruised to the 49-7 win in [...]

By |2024-10-12T23:31:00-04:00October 12th, 2024|18S Reads, Football|7 Comments

Deuce Knight’s Decommitment is the Latest Thing Making This Fan Base Crazy

Top QB recruit Deuce Knight publicly flipped his commitment from Notre Dame to Auburn Wednesday night. Apparently, he was impressed with Auburn making him a priority for 2 months after publicly failing to flip 2 other quarterbacks, versus the two years ND made him their #1. (I'm not bitter at all.) Personally, and I swear [...]

By |2024-10-02T20:33:32-04:00October 2nd, 2024|18S Reads, Football|62 Comments

At Least They Won This Time: Miami (OH) Instant Reaction

For the second straight home game, Notre Dame looked like a tire fire for much of the first half against a MAC opponent Saturday, but this time, at least, the Irish managed to pull itself together and post a workmanlike 28-3 victory over Miami (OH). That should at least calm the frustrated masses who, in [...]

By |2024-09-21T19:41:56-04:00September 21st, 2024|18S Reads, Football|8 Comments

An Annoying Blowout: Purdue Instant Reaction

In the most annoying blowout in Notre Dame football history, the Irish looked like the team we were promised all offseason Saturday, blasting a Purdue team that frankly looked like they were done about seven minutes into the game by a 66-7 margin. With every touchdown, the Irish's utter no-show against Northern Illinois looked more [...]

By |2024-09-14T19:31:28-04:00September 14th, 2024|18S Reads|12 Comments

It’s All Over: Northern Illinois Instant Reaction

Notre Dame is the Make-a-Wish team of college football. I'll explain. Notre Dame only exists as a husk. A former blue blood whose only purpose in this sport is to make dreams come true for other programs. UConn. Tulsa. South Florida. Duke. (A half-dozen other programs nearly joined this list late in the Brian Kelly [...]

By |2024-09-07T19:09:42-04:00September 7th, 2024|18S Reads|30 Comments

Regular Season Games Undone, Part III: LSU/Alabama, 2011

You knew we had to go over this one, right? There have been several other games since the 2000 Miami/FSU game we covered in our last entry way back in 2023 with an argument to be included in this series. Nebraska/Colorado 2001 and the 2003 Big 12 championship game are two obvious candidates, because the [...]

By |2024-05-13T09:23:39-04:00May 13th, 2024|18S Reads, Football|1 Comment
Go to Top