Inspired by Larz’s tremendous piece a few weeks ago and as anticipation builds for the 2016 opener, I’ve been thinking a lot lately about the win over Texas to open 2015. Walking out of the stadium that warm September night, it felt so damn satisfying – defeating a storied program, seemingly answering all kinds of offseason questions and concerns, and fueling overwhelming optimism that this year could be special.

And while in the past we may have developed a reputation for looking back on misery, with series ranking the worst losses in Notre Dame Football history and of the Charlie Weis era, I wanted to look back at some of the happier moments – the games that were most satisfying to watch.

As you’d expect, these rankings are extremely subjective – much of it stems from background, personal grudges, and how the ebbs and flows of the football program match up with our lives. I’ve ranked both the most satisfying games I’ve attended in person and watched remotely here – interested in hearing about others experiences in the comments as well. You’ll notice these are all relatively recent, since my Notre Dame fandom didn’t truly begin until 2005, so I’m sure some folks have much different (but equally awesome) lists.

Top Three Most Satisfying Games

Attended:

3. Notre Dame 38, Texas 3 (2015)

Opening games bring limitless possibilities – there’s a natural giddiness that after a nine month hiatus that football is back, and after week one there’s always the natural rush to judgment to crown new contenders and declare any team that struggled overrated. In recent years results have been cause for both deserved (Navy 2012) and undue (Nevada 2009) optimism, and of course crushing defeats (Georgia Tech 2007, USF 2011).

Some of those crushing defeats caused me to become mostly paranoid of opening games – what if playoff chances are shot after one week? And then Notre Dame just came out are demolished the Longhorns.  Sure, I knew a big part of this was that Texas wasn’t very good, but the Irish answered every offseason question with an exclamation mark. The defense (even the pass rush!) looked strong, Malik Zaire was near-perfect, and I realized CJ Prosise at running back was going to be much better than I ever imagined.

I’m fortunate enough to have family that lives in South Bend – close enough to Notre Dame that walking is actually much faster than driving to or from campus with game-day traffic. I watched the game with my brother-in-law, who afterwards went to go hang out with some friends, so this time I walked back alone.  And that 25 minute walk last year was just about perfect – thinking we had a special team this season, walking by campus landmarks lit up at night, and the electric atmosphere from the game trickling across campus as groups of students went back to dorms to find food and Natty Light to celebrate with.

2. Notre Dame 13, Michigan 6 (2012)

Losing to Michigan is the worst. It took me approximately 0.1 seconds of time attending a Notre Dame-Michigan game to develop an unyielding hatred for Michigan. Their song sucks, maize looks to be the result of a mission to make yellow as annoying as possible, and I cannot comment on their fanbase without this escalating into a 14,000 rant. (Sidenote: one of the best things about 18 Stripes is that we have yet to be discovered by Michigan commenters who love to visit ND blogs. Cherish these days.)

Prior to this game, I had attended three games against Michigan in person – 2006, 2009, and 2010. Those games featured Mario Manningham running towards me for a lot of touchdowns, a last-second loss to Tate Forcier at the Big House, and Denard Robinson becoming a Heisman favorite. I was studying abroad and missed being there the one year we got them as a student, and this was the year after the infamous “Under the Lights”/Denard/Gary Gray game in 2011.

So there were a lot of reasons to be anxious going into that game, chief among them being terrified of Denard Robinson (I really didn’t know the 2012 defense was going to be great quite yet). That night, every interception felt like redemption. I jumped around and screamed myself hoarse yelling “He’s not a quarterback!” with every pick. Unfortunately the Irish offense slogged through the game too, but when Tommy Rees hit Tyler Eifert for the game-clinching first down it was just pure relief.

1. Notre Dame 41, Penn State 17 (2006)

This was my first game in Notre Dame Stadium as a freshman, and it was incredible. This team as you’ll remember was ranked #2 in most preseason polls, but had struggled a bit in the opener at Georgia Tech. The Nittany Lions were ranked 19th at this point, and it seemed like an inflection point at the time – was this Notre Dame team a real contender?

There’s just no way to ever replicate the first time walking into the stadium – taking in the atmosphere, history, and crowd of game day. Unsure of the usual protocol, I showed up about 45 minutes early for the first game, with pretty good results from the student ticket lottery – row 25 or so (which ended up being by far the best I had in my four years). To just sit for a few minutes, taking everything in – that was the real freshman orientation.

Then I had the privilege of taking in an absolute stomping of Joe Paterno and company from the student section. Notre Dame led 20-0 at the half and 34-3 entering the fourth quarter. It was everything I expected and more. All the stars did star-like things, with Brady Quinn throwing for three scores and no picks, Tom Zbikowski scored on a fumble recovery, and the team just made it look really easy all day.In my mind, they were destined for a national championship.

Any first game in Notre Dame Stadium is a special experience, and that one just cemented my love for this team. College football is the best, we were really good, and would definitely be great for the next four years – Charlie Weis was bringing us back to the glory days of Irish football, right? At that point there was no reason to think otherwise

On TV:

1. Notre Dame 37, Michigan 0 (2015) no explanation necessary.

2. Notre Dame 20, Stanford 13 (2012) – I watched this game alone, and at several points thought someone would eventually stumble upon me days later, dead of a heart attack. The defensive struggle featured the best and worst of freshman Everett Golson, Tommy Rees lofting up critical passes late, critical field goal attempts in the rain, and of course the epic goal line stand.

3. Notre Dame 30, Oklahoma 13 (2012) – This game coincided with a work Halloween party, which I put minimal effort towards (my wife and I dressing up as a “bees” with a black shirt and yellow tape) while wearing a green #5 Notre Dame jersey underneath as I had every game of the 2012 season. I found a few other Irish fans that I became quick friends with as we watched this game, aka the one where it became realistic to start talking about a national championship game appearance.