We are breaking down the Notre Dame football prospects ahead of the NFL Draft which begins on Thursday, April 29th in Cleveland, Ohio. There will be no NFL Combine this year due to the pandemic. However, Notre Dame will hold its Pro Day on March 31st at 12:00 PM in South Bend.
Next up, the quarterback with the most wins in Notre Dame history.
SPECS
Name: Ian Book
Position: QB
Height: 6-0 (per the Senior Bowl)
Weight: 210 (per the Senior Bowl)
Hometown: El Dorado Hills, CA
STATS
YEAR | COMP | ATT | YDS | TD | INT |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
2017 | 46 | 75 | 456 | 4 | 4 |
2018 | 214 | 314 | 2628 | 19 | 7 |
2019 | 240 | 399 | 3034 | 34 | 6 |
2020 | 228 | 353 | 2830 | 15 | 3 |
TOTAL | 728 | 1141 | 8948 | 72 | 20 |
BIO:
Notre Dame was debating whether to take a quarterback in the 2016 class when Ian Book engineered a stealth visit to South Bend as a Washington State commit and later gave his verbal to the Irish in August 2015. He would redshirt as a distant 4th-string quarterback behind DeShone Kizer, Malik Zaire, and Brandon Wimbush seemingly years away from seeing the field.
When Kizer and Zaire left town after an embattled 2016 it was Book who moved into the backup role for 2017 seeing quality action in a start against North Carolina and against Miami for a pulled Wimbush. Heading into 2018, Book’s role as a backup looked locked in but he was given the starting job in game 4 and never looked back for the next 2.5 years.
STRENGTHS:
Serene and poised. Leads by example. Accurate in the short-to-intermediate part of the field. Nice and compact throwing motion. Good base and smooth delivery when he sets his feet and is an excellent thrower on the run. Extremely nimble in the pocket and excels being elusive and darting away from pressure. A very good and tough runner who makes big plays with his feet.
WEAKNESSES:
Very poor arm strength, especially when he throws off-platform. Short and doesn’t see the middle of the field very well. Too skittish in the pocket. Not trusting enough in good blocking. Too often struggled making his second or third reads. Has shown flashes of a decent deep ball but doesn’t let it rip enough nor have the natural arm strength to make this a consistent part of his game in the NFL.
OVERVIEW:
I believe I was the first person in the Notre Dame world to call for Book to replace Wimbush back in 2018 and never in the preceding 2.5 years of football did I think that Ian Book would get drafted. After just finishing typing out his weaknesses I still think no way is he getting picked.
However, it seems like there’s a far better chance of it happening than not. One could argue that it doesn’t really matter much if you’re a pick on the last day or a priority free agent signing, especially as a quarterback. An interesting note is that Book has almost 10 inch hands which is more common for quarterbacks who are 6’2″ or 6’3″ and that jumped out to me. Although he’s short he has some freaky athleticism to him that will help him possibly survive in the pro ranks.
PREDICTION:
7th Round, 247th Overall to the Washington Football Team
I originally had Book going to Washington, especially after they released Alex Smith. They have a new 2-year cap-friendly deal signed with Taylor Heinicke plus a restricted free agent tendered offer for Kyle Allen, too.
It’s unlikely that Book jumps right into a backup role and truthfully he may struggle to make a 52-man roster for a year or 2 if he even sticks around in the NFL. Washington doesn’t have a long-term solution at quarterback so taking Book with their final pick does make some sense.
Washington did just sign Ryan Fitzpatrick to a 1-year $10 million deal to essentially be their starter which probably lowers Book’s odds of heading to the franchise. But, I don’t think anyone is looking to the Notre Dame man as their future and Washington has 2 picks in the 7th round to take a chance on Book as a backup down the line.
More Scouting Reports to Come:
Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah
Liam Eichenberg
This seemed like a pretty fair assessment. From my perspective, I think that some of those weaknesses will be too much for most teams, but there’s always a chance that there will be one team that likes his potential as a future backup. My guess — undrafted but gets a shot on a roster.
Book is fascinating. His weaknesses of not being comfortable in a pocket or reading the defense or trusting down field throws and not having a strong arm all adds up to not being a great NFL QB.
But teams will love he’s a competitor, mobile, supposedly very smart. All great traits for a backup. Depending on the system, maybe something west coast offense, short quick throws, RPO’s, that kind of stuff, he might work out too in the right spot.
I think he’ll get drafted somewhere as a developmental option for a team that has a good QB. Not sure when. Wouldn’t be shocked if it’s higher than the 7th round just because of the importance of QB’s (ala Minshew and McSorely being drafted in the 6th as sort of similar profiles).
I deeply hope he will fix three of the four flaws in your first para, Hooks… and that the incredible competitive flame as per your second para will bring him to Drew Brees levels that none think possible right now. Hope is not a method but it is a virtue.