This is the first week for the official College Football Playoff committee rankings. Hey, SMU and Appalachian State have been cruising – let’s discuss the probability that a Group of 5 team will finally make it into the playoff!
The final two G5 undefeateds fell this weekend, so that was fun while it lasted.
Possible resume wins are listed in schedule order, and won’t include potential conference championship game participation until we get closer to that weekend – at this point, if a P5 team is still on the board they have a path to the conference title game. The “538 Table-Running Probability” is taken from the nifty predictor tool available here. I don’t have a preference for 538’s table over SP+, FEI, FPI, or other advanced stats models – they all have pros and cons. 538’s presentation is just the easiest to work with for these purposes.
Undefeated Teams
An undefeated Power 5 team will always control its own destiny. All these teams are thus sitting pretty for the playoff as of today.
#1 Ohio State
This week: vs. Maryland
Resume wins to date: vs. #20 Cincinnati, vs. #13 Wisconsin
Possible resume wins: vs. #4 Penn State, at #14 Michigan
538 table-running probability: 47%
Ohio State is the big winner in the first committee rankings, checking in at #1 here versus #3 in the AP poll. The elevation of them above LSU is interesting; they’ve been more dominant, certainly, with an average margin of victory of 41 points versus LSU’s 27, but LSU has clearly played a better schedule so far. All very academic, of course, as LSU would certainly pass them with a win this week.
#2 LSU
This week: at #3 Alabama
Resume wins to date: vs. #10 Florida, vs. #11 Auburn
Possible resume wins: at #3 Alabama
538 table-running probability: 17%
We’ll note again that Texas could conceivably creep into the back end of the rankings before the season is over, adding another “quality win” for the committee. Their game with Alabama this week is the matchup of the season so far and perhaps the rest of the way as well, with all apologies to #1 Ohio State and #4 Penn State. LSU will take the field in Tuscaloosa as the higher-ranked team for the first time since 2015, when the #4 Tigers fell 30-16 to the #7 Tide. A win this week would vault LSU to #1 and give them a relatively clear path to the top seed of the playoff.
#3 Alabama
This week: vs. #2 LSU
Resume wins to date: None
Possible resume wins: vs. #2 LSU, at #11 Auburn
538 table-running probability: 27%
Alabama, like LSU, comes into this massive matchup off a bye. Alabama has been utterly dominant as usual, but LSU is the first opponent they’ll face in the current rankings and only the second opponent they’ll face that was ranked at game time (the other was then-#24 Texas A&M, who is 3-3 against Power 5 competition). In addition to doubts about how tested the Tide have been this year, Tua Tagovailoa is officially a game-time decision. Backup Mac Jones did well last time out against Arkansas, but (a) it’s Arkansas and (b) Tua is Tua.
#4 Penn State
This week: at #17 Minnesota
Resume wins to date: at #18 Iowa, vs. #14 Michigan
Possible resume wins: at #17 Minnesota, at #1 Ohio State
538 Table-Running Probability: 13%
Penn State’s matchup with Minnesota this week provides a key test for both teams. Penn State has shown well in games against Iowa and Michigan but won both by a combined 12 points. They’re good, but how good are they? A road date in balmy Minneapolis will put the Nittany Lions’ bona fides on the line. If they get out of there, they host a respectable Indiana team before traveling to Columbus to take on the Big Ten’s 800-pound gorilla.
#5 Clemson
This week: at North Carolina State
Resume wins to date: None
Possible resume wins: vs. #22 Wake Forest
538 table-running probability: 68%
Nothing quite highlights the putrid state of the ACC than Clemson’s laughably weak schedule. Clemson went up against FCS Wofford last week, faces a moribund NC State this week, hosts a not-terrible Wake Forest the next week, has a week off, and then visits a moribund South Carolina. They’ve faced only three opponents to date who have a winning record this season. Blech. If they win out they’ll get in, but it’s hard to see how they could climb back up to the top seed.
#12 Baylor
This week: at TCU
Resume wins to date: at #16 Kansas State
Possible resume wins: vs. #9 Oklahoma
538 table-running probability: 6%
Baylor snuck past a so-so West Virginia at home on Halloween, which is their fourth single-score win this year. Maybe why the committee has six blemished teams ahead of this undefeated Power 5 team, despite a commanding win over the #16 team, which beat the #9 team. Transitive property, and all that. Anyway, after a winnable matchup with TCU this week they’ll host that #9 team the following week, so they’ll get a chance to move.
#17 Minnesota
This week: vs. #4 Penn State
Resume wins to date: None
Possible resume wins: vs. #4 Penn State, at #18 Iowa, vs. #13 Wisconsin
538 table-running probability: 2%
The season so far has been a dramedy in two parts for the 8-0 Golden Gophers. They won their first four games by a combined 20 points; their opponents were an FCS team, two Group of 5 teams, and a bad Purdue team. Not great. They won their second four games by a combined 127 points; their opponents were Illinois, Nebraska, Rutgers, and Maryland. If we’re being honest the second group isn’t much better than the first group, but still, that’s impressive. They have a chance to Row the Boat™ right into the middle of the national discussion this week.
Group of 5 Teams
One Loss Teams
These teams aren’t out of it but will need some breaks to fall their way. The good news for them is that every college football season contains a looooot of breaks.
#6 Georgia
This week: vs. Missouri
Resume wins to date: vs. #15 Notre Dame, vs. #10 Florida (neutral site)
Possible resume wins: at #11 Auburn
The one loss: at South Carolina
538 table-running probability: 14%
The committee rewarded what is clearly the nation’s best one-loss resume, despite that one loss being pretty awful. Setting the loss to Will Muschamp aside, LSU and Georgia are the only teams in the country with two top 15 wins at the moment. Georgia is in the driver’s seat for the SEC East title after knocking off Florida last week, which leaves them very much in control of their playoff destiny. Should they handle a Missouri that is suddenly reeling this week, they may even head to Auburn next week as a top five team.
#7 Oregon
This week: Off
Resume wins to date: None
Possible resume wins: None
The one loss: vs. #11 Auburn (neutral site)
538 table-running probability: 44%
Early in the second quarter, Oregon intercepted USC QB Kedon Slovis in the end zone with USC leading 10-0. From that point forward, the Ducks went on a 56-14 scoring run to bludgeon the Trojans into submission. The road domination was undoubtedly Oregon’s most complete performance of the season, but unfortunately for them, that’s not saying much with that their schedule looks like. With no ranked wins in the bank and only Arizona, Arizona State, and Oregon State left, they’re almost certainly going to finish the regular season with no ranked wins. That’s a tough sell for the committee, but things could weird if they win out and beat a top-10 Utah in the Pac 12 title game.
#8 Utah
This week: Off
Resume wins to date: None
Possible resume wins: None
The one loss: at USC
538 table-running probability: 32%
Utah won in Seattle last weekend, which is no small feat. Like Alabama, they have yet to face any currently ranked teams, and like Oregon, they’re not going to face any either. They’re in good shape to make the Pac 12 title game, probably against Oregon, and will probably need some help to get in the playoff but they’re definitely still alive.
#9 Oklahoma
This week: vs. Iowa State
Resume wins to date: None
Possible resume wins: at #12 Baylor
The one loss: at #16 Kansas State
538 table-running probability: 26%
The Sooners had a week off to mull over their upset loss to Kansas State, which threw a serious wrench in their playoff plans. They host a respectable Iowa State this week before traveling to Baylor – if they get caught looking ahead, Iowa State is more than capable of giving them their second straight upset loss.
#19 Wake Forest
This week: at Virginia Tech
Resume wins to date: None
Possible resume wins: at #4 Clemson
The one loss: vs. Louisville
538 table-running probability: 2%
The Demon Deacons obliterated North Carolina State in a game that wasn’t as close as the 44-10 final indicates. That was a welcome reversal in a schedule that featured one-score margins against every other FBS opponent, including their three-point loss to Louisville. I’m sure if they win by more than one in Blacksburg this week it won’t lead to any dissension in the Irish fanbase. Right?
Off the Board
#10 Florida could still possibly sneak in but it would require so many huge upsets – including them over whoever comes out of the SEC West and additional extraconference insanity – that it seems more than fair to say they’re dead.
#25 SMU got behind big at #18 Memphis and a furious rally came up just short. Similarly, NR Appalachian State tried to storm back against Georgia Southern but couldn’t quite pull it off. Each needs to now hope that the other plus Boise State and Memphis slip up to get back into position for the Group of 5’s automatic NY6 bid. That’s a long, long way from playoff contention.
It’ll be very interesting to see what the committee does with the 1 loss LSU/Bama team that presumably won’t go the SECCG. I’d reckon most probably think they loser of that game is still possibly one of the top-4 teams in the country (even though, in Bama’s case there would be no resume to prove it).
Do the PAC12/BIG12 get shutout? And the committee end up with an undefeated Clemson (4) vs. SEC Champ (1) and Ohio State* (2) vs. LSU/Bama loser (3)?
(*Sub undefeated PSU for tOSU if it comes from that, this also assumes the SEC West winner beats UGA in SECCG..) That’s very clean and convenient but it looks like PAC12 champ + Oklahoma need a lot of chaos — namely for Clemson to lose — in order to get a playoff spot.
Yea how could Bama get in the playoffs if it loses to LSU?
Yeah that’s too clean and convenient. The Big Ten is going to have a tough time producing an undefeated champ with the schedules left. Bama is screwed if they lose to LSU.
Here is my dream, semi-realistic, hilarious chaos scenario:
Clemson loses to Wake, Wake makes conference championship, loses to UVA/Pitt/whoever. ACC is screwed.
Penn State beat Minnesota, IU beats Penn State, Penn State beats Ohio State, Wisconsin beats PSU in Championship. BIG10 is screwed.
Herm Edwards stuns Oregon, Oregon beats Utah in Pac12 championship. Pac12 is screwed.
Bama beats LSU, loses to Auburn, loses to Georgia/Florida in Conference championship. Bama is screwed.
Georgia loses to Auburn. Georgia/Florida beats Bama in Conference championship. SEC champ has 2 losses, is screwed.
LSU loses to Bama, misses conference championship. SEC’s only team in the playoff is now a team not in their conference championship game, ND forever laughs at people saying only conference champs should be in.
Baylor loses to Oklahoma and Texas. Baylor is screwed.
Oklahoma beats Baylor, loses conference championship vs Texas. Big12 is screwed.
NCAA cancels the playoff, just declares Ed Orgeron’s accent the national champion..