Notre Dame has been playing football for 135 years and along the way some momentous decisions were made to shape the history of this storied program now entering a daring new phase of college sports. This off-season, we look back at the 10 best decisions made for the Fighting Irish in the decades past.
#3
The NBC Television Deal
Ahead of the game, controversial, and the first domino to fall in the wider control from television and media over college football. Over 34 years ago, Notre Dame dove head first into the sports media money machine with a historic television deal that sent shockwaves through college sports.
All the way back in 1977, Notre Dame joined teams from the ACC, Big 8, SEC, Southwestern, WAC, plus independents Army, Navy, Air Force, Penn State, Pittsburgh, and West Virginia to form the College Football Association (CFA) in an effort to negotiate their own television deals separate from the NCAA’s decision making and control.
When the first CFA television deals were agreed upon, the NCAA filed suit and in the landmark NCAA vs. Board of Regents of University of Oklahoma case the Supreme Court ruled that the NCAA’s television control violated the Sherman Antitrust Act.
In 1984, with free control from the NCAA and deregulation, the CFA signed TV deals with ABC and CBS while the Big Ten and Pac-10 sold their own packages separately to ABC.
The 4th game broadcast in the ND-NBC TV deal.
Just over 6 years later, the CFA was in the process of negotiating a new deal. In October of 1989 (with Notre Dame the current undefeated National Champions and on a long winning streak) a new CFA deal with ESPN for 5 years and $110 million was agreed upon, followed up by another deal with ABC for 5 years and $210 million a few months later in January 1990.
All seemed well, except Notre Dame did not agree to the new deals.
The Fighting Irish leadership were frustrated by all but the 3 Notre Dame-USC home games in South Bend in the new contract being shown regionally instead of nationally. Notre Dame athletic director Dick Rosenthal said at the time, “It would almost be better for us not to be on [television] than to be on in only part of the country.”
Notre Dame wouldn’t wait long to make a move. Just 10 days after the CFA-ABC deal, the Irish negotiated a fresh 5-year deal with NBC to nationally televise all Notre Dame football home games. Terms of the deal were not disclosed but it was rumored to pay $10 million per year (roughly $24 million in today’s money) and would begin in with the 1991 football season.
The CFA was not long for this world after Notre Dame’s decision. In 1995, the SEC and Big East negotiated its own TV deal with CBS and the 1996 college football season would be the last for the CFA members collectively. Notre Dame had kicked down the door and the 1990’s would include ABC/ESPN overcoming the changes to tighten their grip over the sport with massive television and media deals signed all over the college football landscape like with the 1998 deal between ABC and the newly created BCS for $930 million over 8 seasons.
For Notre Dame, it was a pioneering move that felt a little ahead of its time but also something that many could’ve and should’ve seen coming. More importantly, the decision to sign with NBC–while frustrating at times today that they are still in a relationship that isn’t always perfect–has tremendously helped Notre Dame to stay independent in football and continue to have a powerful bargaining chip as a national brand in the playoff era of the sport.
Whoops, this was supposed to go up next Monday but oh well. A rare 2-for-1 Monday article drop in the off-season!
Woohoo! It’s like we all get the 18S VIP membership perk of seeing articles a week early, only it’s free this week!
Conflicting thoughts on this one.
The NBC deal was a good decision because, as you say, it allowed ND to remain independent right as all the old independents (Penn State, Miami, etc.) were shacking up with conferences. In particular, the NBC deal almost certainly saved us from being forced into the B1G on bad terms during the Dark Ages of 1996-2011.
But the what the NBC deal has become is, IMO, pretty frustrating. ND football broadcasts are a laboratory for NBC’s worst ideas and announcers. The relationship is a bastion of inside baseball and nepotism. NBC knows that they have no real competition and thus have little motive to improve. I’ll judge Bevacqua on his own merits, but the fact that we hired an AD straight from our TV broadcaster should raise more than a few eyebrows.
Amen on the second paragraph. It’s BRUTAL to get the AAA farm league of announcers and broadcast changes before they call them up to the NFL broadcasts.
I also get the impression that part of the national ND narrative is negatively affected because half our games are on NBC, which is not a prime time hub of college football, so many casual viewers are not seeking out watching ND games that aren’t prime time. Couple that with the almost pro-other-team announcing from NBC, (looking at YOU flutie flakes) this relationship, BK era onwards maybe has strained our brand perception.
A lot of times, it’s more enjoyable watching ND on ESPN where we get standard, modern GameDay treatment with good announcers.
I have taken a page out of my uncles book though, and mute the TV during games and either listen to music or the radio broadcast for a more pleasurable experience. That doesn’t affect some of the silly NBC camera angles or technical difficulties.
Was this #1 and then Sideline Skycam happened?
(ppl forget Sideline Skycam; it was real bad)
Well, i had forgotten it…
There was a funny Swarbrick quote after the first or second game it was used where he was like “oh, it’s great, you’re going to get used to it and love it” and then by three games later they were completely done with it because everyone (correctly) hated it.
I definitely think NBC has been a net positive but I do wonder how it’ll evolve with the B1G deal
Not sure I like potentially playing second fiddle to something like the modern Big Ten
A hilarious hypothetical would be to snag up CBS to enrage the SEC folks
Back to NBC man they’ve had some banger themes for ND games
https://youtu.be/lj0o0CRV92I?si=UUxQ6a4-zvVHfn0y
https://youtu.be/MyuFVGK2KrY?si=DegY60CnfTpt9u7x