Well, recent events certainly changed the dynamic of this article which began several weeks ago.
For the sake of this thorough study I won’t be including any new Power 5 programs, and I’m not sure anyone would even include the likes of Cincinnati, BYU, or Houston in this discussion anyway. You could simply list the all-time worst winning percentages among the Power 5 programs and that would include all of Duke, Kansas, Kansas State, Indiana, Rutgers, Northwestern, Iowa State, Oregon State, Mississippi State, and Vanderbilt. Each of those football programs are still under .500 in their history. Yet, we must dig deeper.
I wanted to include a few teams but decided against it, so these are the ‘receiving votes’ programs:
Kansas – Historically they deserve extremely careful consideration but at the same time they are on a nice upward trend now.
Georgia Tech – They are going through struggles but aren’t that far removed from sustained success, plus they have some pieces to make some noise pulling in-state recruits.
Duke – If we’re honest they should make the top 5. However, Old Man Elko has this program improving just enough to keep them out.
Arizona – If we’re chronicling strengths, it doesn’t make a ton of sense why Arizona has been so poor throughout their history. They’ve largely been really bad!
Rutgers – Typically it’s not great if you’re nicknamed Buttgers.
Mississippi State – Way too much success this century to make it but if you’re looking at the SEC this isn’t one of the places you want to be.
The Top 5 Worst Power 5 Conference Programs
#5 IndianaÂ
Harsh considering they finished 12th in the country only back in 2020. Still, that was a shortened Covid year and it’s really hard to overlook the vast amount of seasons where the Hoosiers have been average to bad throughout their history. I was born in 1982 and there have been just 8 seasons since then where Indiana finished with a winning record. The 2020 season mentioned above is the only time they’ve even finished ranked in the AP Poll since the fall of the Berlin Wall.
Are they too overshadowed by the basketball team?
Explain yourself, Indiana.Â
Sure, they got stuck in the hard Big Ten division in recent years. However, they have one of the most beautiful campuses in college football in a fairly advantageous location that can pull from a swath of Midwestern suburban areas within reasonable driving distance. It’s a good academic school but it can’t be holding the Hoosiers back like some other places in their position. It seemed like Tom Allen was going to be the guy to finally turn Indiana around and increase their ceiling just enough to what felt should be more appropriate–and it’s not happening.
#4 Washington State
Unfortunately, Washington State didn’t have a lot going for it long-term (although they’ve done a commendable job persevering at times throughout their history despite the odds) and in recent days they may well on their way to being removed from this list as a formality.
Poor Wazzu may be relegated from the Power 5. Maybe Stanford should be on this list, too?
If they are able to stay you could argue there are worst programs to be in the country. The Cougars have 8 seasons where they finished ranked since 1988 which isn’t terrible for a team on this list. Heck, they were 10th and won the Alamo Bowl just a few years ago, RIP Mike Leach. However, with their future so tenuous we’re placing them 4th in today’s countdown.
#3 Boston College
It hasn’t been a super dark decade+ for the Eagles, but it’s been pretty poor and they are arguably as badly positioned as any of the Power 5 programs to continue surviving and being able to increase their profile. They were probably the worst team in the ACC last year and are currently on their 3rd straight coach spinning his wheels unable to make progress in Chestnut Hill.
BC players don’t even want to be at BC.
What is there to like? They are situated in a bad region for college football recruiting and overshadowed from all corners by professional sports. Boston College also hasn’t finished a season ranked since 2007. They really do suck.
#2 Vanderbilt
Good luck to our boy Clark Lea. He did sign a contract extension through 2029 after just 7 wins through 2 seasons in Nashville which tells you enough about how low the bar is set for the school. But hey, they did beat Kentucky and Florida last year.
This job is so incredibly difficult with academic standards and some of the worst history among the Power 5. Most seasons they are simply swallowed up by the SEC. Think about this…Vanderbilt doesn’t have a single top 10 finish ever in their history. They had those back-to-back James Franklin years where the scheduling Gods aligned perfectly–other than that they’ve finished ranked just one other time all the way back in 1948.
Just 2 notable seasons in over 70 years is wild.
#1 Northwestern
A good question would be where Northwestern would’ve landed on this list prior to this summer? Within the Big Ten I believe their lows have been lower than Indiana. However, Northwestern has a much better track record of pulling out a decent-to-good season far more often than the Hoosiers. If Indiana only has 8 winning seasons in my lifetime, Northwestern has 7 seasons where they finished ranked by the AP Poll over that same timespan.
Now, though?
What hath he wrought?Â
The school was still up and down befitting their place in the college football orbit but at the same time performing at one of their highest levels in history and have now blown it up after a bizarre and disgusting hazing culture torpedoed the coaching career of one of their most famous football players.
So far, 6 players have decommitted this summer and Northwestern stands at only 9 commits for 2024, 12 spots lower overall than aforementioned Indiana this cycle. Plus, it’ll likely only get much worse before it even begins to get better. We are probably headed to a dark period for Northwestern with on-field results.
I would like to throw Illinois into the mix here, at least based on recent history. Over the past 20 years:
-86-154 record
-best year was a 9 win season, 16 years ago, ending the season ranked 20th
-only 4 seasons over .500
-Five seasons with 2 wins and one season with 1 win
Their ancient history is solid enough, with some Rose Bowls and even some claimed National Titles. But boy have they been bad the past 2 decades. One of the weirdly intriguing storylines to watch in the Big Ten the next 2-3 years is if Bielema is actually turning the program around, or if he just lucked into having 3 extremely good DBs (all of whom have been drafted and are gone), who covered up major flaws in the program.
Doesn’t seem like Illinois has any long-term strategy for the program. They went from being a spread team with suspiciously good recruiting under Zook, to a blob of nothing under Beckman, to focusing heavily on recruiting St. Louis under Lovie, to a super power run and defense team under Bielema. What are they trying to be? I have no idea.
Yes agree with Illinois! Northwestern at #1 seems a bit much. They’ve been in big 10 champ contention several times
JFC, I didn’t realize the good for Illinois was so bad.
I second throwing Illinois on here. As an Illinoisian who was an early teen during the Kitner/Brandon Lloyd teams they were my second favorite team behind ND. It’s insane how bad they’ve been in football the past 30 years. Honestly, shocking how bad they’ve been in basketball too since 2005.
The incompetence and squandering of money from these Big Ten schools is baffling. Minnesota, Indiana, UofI, Northwestern all should be pretty ashamed for the football and bball programs they’ve trotted out for the better part of the past 20 years.
Also, no one goes to Illinois games, not sure if that factors in at all
Agreed, while I haven’t been to a game in Memorial Stadium in 20 years, it still just looks depressing on TV even when they have had bigger games.
Also for basketball they’ve upgraded Assembly Hall (now State Farm Center) and it now feels on TV like you’re watching a game at the United Center with all the seats close to the court moving away from the students and to more higher priced fan purchases. Admittedly have done zero research if this is actually the case, just going off what I have observed on TV.
IMO, there’s a case to be made that the right answer at the moment is the Pac-4 and Northwestern.
A forgotten but hilarious game — Syracuse at BC 2004. Last week of the regular season, BC was 8-2 and ranked #17. All they had to do to win the Big East and secure a BCS bowl was beat lowly 5-win Syracuse, who was coming off a loss to Temple.
BC lost 43-17 at home and handed the Big East title and Fiesta Bowl bid to Pitt. It was great seeing BC — especially their annoying teams of that era — get a taste of their own medicine.
just a(n) hilarious statement, in or out of context.
Extra hilarious points for the transitive loss to a Temple program that was being kicked out of the Big East after the season for being bad at football
I’m rooting for Oregon State to win the PAC 12 this year, not likely, but they have an outside chance. Kind of a big ‘Piss Off’ to all the schools that voted for money over tradition and headed out to the Big X.
Boston College football the last 10 years
7-6
7-6
3-9
7-6
7-6
7-5
6-7
6-5
6-6
3-9
lol
one of my earliest happy cfb memories is bc’s QB with a serious pout face after the 2009 game
The last time I remember Illinois being consistently good was in the Dick Butkus era of the early sixties. Rice has been consistently horrid most of my life.
Rice_Owls_football
Except for the past dozen years or so, Baylor has been terrible.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baylor_Bears_football
GT actually has a pretty good football history although most of it is sixties or before. They have been awarded the NC seven times by different organizations.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgia_Tech_Yellow_Jackets_football
Wake Forest is fourth from the bottom of all teams and not just Power 5. They would have to be #1 although they are doing a little better now.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgia_Tech_Yellow_Jackets_football
I have pretty detailed memories of the Illinois Juice Williams Rose Bowl season in 2007 since ND didn’t play that year. They were exciting to watch, won at home against #5 Wisconsin and then on the road at #1 Ohio State.
I remember that Illini team completing the traditional Big 10 cycle of winning the conference and getting blasted in the Rose Bowl.
If you can’t beat USC in the Rose Bowl, add USC to your conference ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Narrow the choices down to records against FBS competition only.
With arguably four of the top six Pac teams, NW, Indiana and Illinois records against P5 teams can only get worse. The budding rivalries of Washington-Northwestern and Oregon-Indiana are must sees.
Off the subject – The Oregon-Oregon State rivalry, first played continuously since 1894, is over since both teams have three non-conference games scheduled through 2024-2027 – unless both each pay a scheduled opponent to cancel a game. Washington-Washington State have played each other since 1900.
“Narrow the choices down to records against FBS competition only.”
Nah, I’d narrow it down to winning percentage vs. FCS competition only. That will show you the teams that can’t even pad their schedules to avoid looking like morons.
In additon to NW and Indiana, Rutgers, Illinois and Maryland are much worse than Washington State. The first four have been addressed. Disregarding the Covid year and including bowl games, Maryland is 23-47 against P5 competition over 2015-22. In the same time frame, Washington State is 38-23, also against P5 foes over the same period.
I thought that outside of crab cakes, football is what Maryland does?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0_2ADWBZgS8
Add Nebraska to the BIG losers. Record against P5 schools – 24-47 over the same time period as above, which is almost identical to Maryland’s.
They lost against Ga Southern at home and to NW last year. (But beat Indian and Rutgers). Their last winning season was 2016. Great stadium, fanbase and history, but shouldn’t they make the Top Ten?
Home and home for Colorado in ’23 and ’24. UCLA in ’24, ’25. USC in ’25. Oregon and Washington scheduling is pending. Imagine Nebraska future BIG schedules including all four of them to lessen travel. I imagine they would duck a home-and-homes with Washington State or Oregon State.
Team I predict to be on the list if you do this again in 3 years: Iowa State. Really bad historically. 103-144 in the last 20 years. Only 1 top 25 finish in the last 20 years (covid season). Only 1 season in SCHOOL HISTORY where they finished in sole possession of first place in the conference (covid season). Followed that up by going 7-6 then 4-8. Matt Campbell just had the best 5 year stretch in school history, and they only won 61% of those games.
The preseason Big 12 media poll has them only finishing ahead of the newcomers and West Virginia this year.
To your point, I don’t know why Indiana remains so terrible. It must be emphasis on basketball over football. Or just constantly being overshadowed by nearby powers like Ohio State, Michigan, Michigan State, Notre Dame. Indianapolis gets attention from Ohio State; St. Louis from Mizzou, Illinois, Iowa; Chicago from UofI, Michigan, Wisconsin, Iowa.
Indiana high schools don’t produce a ton of football talent, and great products are often snapped up by ND, Ohio State, Michigan and others. Kentucky and Cincinnati are recently threats for the southern portion of the state. Then of course there are two other Power 5 schools in the state, Purdue and Notre Dame, with much more historical success. Contrast that to the state of Ohio who, until recently, only had one Power 5 team and waaaay more high school talent.
Purdue has accomplished a lot by employing relatively innovative coaches. Indiana had some moderate success under Kevin Wilson, a well-regarded offensive mind, but Tom Allen doesn’t have that same background and it seems that the Hoosiers are regressing again. Doesn’t look promising, but of course just one right hire can make a difference!
Nobody at IU cares about football. Maybe it’s because they’ve been so bad for so long, maybe they’ve been bad because nobody cares. But basketball is the one and only priority. Even when the basketball team stinks, students and fans show up. When the football team is “good” the students still leave at halftime to party.
There has also been a bit of bad luck in regards to coaching. Terry Hoeppner died from a brain tumor in 2007 after just 2 seasons as head coach. Whether he was the man to turn things around or not is debatable, but there was clearly excitement building around the program before his passing.
In 2015/2016, Kevin Wilson made back to back bowl games for just the third time in school history. He was then fired for player mistreatment/mishandling of injuries. If IU was a football school or this was a decade earlier, he probably doesn’t get fired. Bob Knight did many worse things than he did. OSU had no problem hiring him one month after his firing. I’m not saying he shouldn’t have been fired, but just that a different program at IU or a different school than IU may have treated the situation differently.
Eh, I probably should have added Rutgers for sure.
https://twitter.com/TheAthletic/status/1688641410075922432?s=20