As expected, a defensive battle broke out in Chicago between Notre Dame and Wisconsin with the Badgers clinging to a 3-point lead early in the 4th quarter. With the Irish quarterback sidelined due to a leg injury things were starting to look a little bleak for Notre Dame. Instead, one of the most fun and frankly laughable 4th quarters in recent memory led to a blowout win for the good guys.

Stats Package
STAT IRISH WISCY
Score 41 13
Plays 69 (nice) 69 (nice)
Total Yards 242 318
Yards Per Play 3.50 4.60
Conversions 6/17 1/15
Completions 21 18
Yards/Pass Attempt 6.45 5.85
Rushes 32 28
Rushing Success 36.0% 38.4%
10+ Yds Rushes 0 1
20+ Yds Passes 3 3
Defense Stuff Rate 23.1% 29.4%

 

Notre Dame’s offense on the whole did not have a very good day at all. However, you have to absolutely love the perseverance from all phases of the team, overcoming a 4th quarter deficit and the loss of the starting quarterback with the Freeman defense coming through for its strongest performance of the year.

What if I told you Notre Dame would be losing in the 4th quarter, totaled 57 offensive yards for the entire 2nd half and would win by 28 points? Anything can happen when it’s the Shamrock Series, baby.

Offense

QB: C+
RB: B-
TE: C
OL: D
WR: B-

First, let’s hand all the accolades to Drew Pyne who came into the game in a tough spot having been demoted essentially to 3rd string with the emergence of Tyler Buchner. Yet, Buchner has a bad hamstring and Pyne had to spend all week getting ready just in case. And his moment finally came against a fearsome defense.

Pyne finished 6 of 8 for 81 yards, pretty decent numbers for playing almost an entire half with some late clock-eating snaps once the score got out of hand. He did get blind-sided and lost a fumble but showed some nice legs to get out of the pocket and move the ball through the air.

To me, Pyne’s touchdown pass to take a 24-13 lead with 9:34 remaining in the game will go down as one of the biggest moments of the season. The Irish had just entered the red zone and lost 4 yards on a 1st down run–normally the offense has stalled in these moments and they should kick a field goal. Instead, Pyne remains calm in the pocket and throws an absolute dart to Kevin Austin for the touchdown.

The 22-yard pass to Mayer that brought things into the red zone 2 plays prior was also a ballsy throw with beautiful touch, too.

I’m sure there are a lot of mixed emotions for Jack Coan who surely is happy Notre Dame beat his former team but did so pulling away after he was injured. He also now has 2 teammates who the coaching staff can trust to come in and play in his absence which probably isn’t a huge confidence boost for Coan.

I thought Coan played okay, pretty inconsistent but that was to be expected given the strength of the Wisconsin front 7 harassing him for 5 sacks (which doesn’t even count the loss of yards after Coan tripped over his own player). The offense continues to struggle getting a rhythm with a short-passing game and can’t loosen up the edges of the defense as a result. They also didn’t get the ball to Kyren Williams through the air, which is very odd.

What are you doing, Jack!??

After the game, Brian Kelly said Coan is still the starting quarterback (assuming he’s healthy I suppose) which is fine for now. I think Coan has to really look in the mirror and do a better job in the pocket and avoid the turtling like in the above GIF to give the offense a chance. That was on a 3rd & 10 from the Wisconsin 30-yard line with 3.9 seconds worth of protection. Under no scenario should that be a sack against a veteran 6’4″ quarterback. Color guy Joel Klatt highlighted on the replay that Avery Davis came wide open to Coan’s left after his drop, too. You have to stand tall and throw the ball, run, or escape the pocket on a play like this…a sack just can’t happen.

As per usual, the offensive line didn’t play well while being unable to open holes in the running game although I will still contend, like I did last week, that they’re far more consistent in pass-protection except for a few blunders. This feels like an issue that will continue to compound with Coan unless he gets the passing offense going at about a 30% better clip. If not, the more mobile (and frankly athletically exciting) quarterbacks will remain a more enticing option.

With this defense, an offense that can remain on schedule, cut out some sacks, and liven the run game up with quarterback movement could be the best recipe. We shall see.

Rushing Success

Williams – 5 of 18 (27.7%)
Tyree – 1 of 2 (50.0%)
Coan – 3 of 4 (75.0%)
Pyne – 0 of 1 (0.0%)

Net 3 yards rushing with the hindsight of the win, well, yeah that’s pretty funny. Even with sacks removed, it was only 42 yards rushing. Not a single run of at least 10 yards! Kyren and Tyree got a combined 20 carries for 39 yards and a long of 7 yards. Yes, the offense ran the ball far too much in this game.

With the chips down, we saw the trio of Mayer/Austin/Davis get things done with 17 catches for 192 yards and of course those 2 huge touchdowns from Austin who had a terrific bounce back game from the Purdue debacle. That production came on 26 targets while Wilkins and Lenzy only mustered 3 catches for 41 yards on 9 targets. The Irish really need something more out of those two.

Defense

DL: A-
LB: B+
DB: B+

They are who we thought they were! Wisconsin’s offense, that is. There were some breaks in the Irish defense as Wisconsin totaled 155 yards (48.7% of their offense) on their 7 biggest plays, although the last 3 came later in the 4th quarter with the game essentially over.

That left the Badgers gaining only 2.58 yards per play on their other 63 snaps.

Notre Dame completely kept the Wisconsin run game in check and then some. Their longest run was just 10 yards–and with how poorly the Irish ground game has been all year–they basically fought to a draw in this area on Saturday. Ultimately that’s a huge win for Notre Dame. The Badgers seemed lost while unable to run the ball and give their passing game breathing room.

I actually thought the pressure from Notre Dame’s front 7 wasn’t great. Early on it seemed to really bother Wisconsin but I thought they did pretty well picking up protections and making adjustments. The Irish finished with only 1 sack and just 4 tackles for loss.

Stuffs vs. Wisconsin

White – 2
Foskey – 2
Lacey – 2
Ademilola, Jay – 2
Ademilola, Jus – 2
Cross – 1
Mills – 1
Kiser – 1
Bertrand – 1
Botelho – 1
Lewis – 1

My goodness though, Graham Mertz really struggled and their insistence on handing him the keys last year while not exactly being upset Coan transferred is looking like a complete folly at this point. Granted, Mertz was taking over sooner or later anyway, but still.

Wisconsin only converted 1 third down the entire game–a fullback dive on 3rd & 1 late in the 3rd quarter. Marcus Freeman took a bet that Notre Dame would get Wisconsin into plenty of 3rd downs and win the day, which they did in a big, big way. Here’s Graham Mertz’ performance on 3rd down:

8 incompletions
2 completions for 8 yards
1 pass interference
1 fumble not lost
1 fumble lost
1 sack
2 interceptions

If you’re curious, yes this was the worst passer rating of Mertz’ career so far.

Final Thoughts

No lie, at one point this week I wondered when the last kickoff return for touchdown happened for Notre Dame. They seemed weirdly aggressive on kickoffs against Wisconsin early and gave up free yardage but they must have scouted something they liked this week. Tyree for 96 yards!

Was anyone at the game and thought the notorious windy Chicago weather affected some of the longer throws for both sides?

Wisconsin and Notre Dame just played a game that combined for 6 rushing first downs.

Notre Dame remains undefeated in Shamrock Series games.

Saturday was the 2nd lowest rushing total for Wisconsin since the 2018 season began.

11 penalties for 93 yards is a big yikes for Notre Dame. Had things played out differently we may have looked back at this a lot differently. Although, you have to love Kelly’s unsportsmanlike penalty for sticking up for Kyle Hamilton.

The Shamrock Series uniforms looked pretty good. I’m a huge fan of the large plain white numbers with no gold outline. I wish they move to that look with the standard home jerseys.

I’m convinced we’ll see Pyne and Buchner make starts at some point this season. Coan is already hurt and/or banged up while the trust in the other 2 is only going to grow as we progress towards November.

Don’t sleep on that 72-yard Jay Bramblett punt. He booted it from the Irish 7-yard line and the returner was back-pedaling from his own 40 when the ball landed behind him at the 30-yard line. Whoops!

In the absence of 5th-year senior captain Kurt Hinish I thought Howard Cross and Jacob Lacey had outstanding games. They each brings high-level run-stopping ability and can penetrate into the backfield when needed, too.

Who was the last Irish quarterback to throw 2 pick sixes in a game? I can’t even imagine dealing with that let alone watching it happen within 4 offensive snaps.

Notre Dame is totally dropping in this week’s SP+ rankings, aren’t they?

This was a nice win for Brian Kelly as he surpassed Knute Rockne for the most wins in school history. We know the score with the history, of course. Kelly isn’t in the same conversation and took about 2 full modern football schedules more of games to best the legendary Rockne with 27 more losses on his resume, too. However, this was a a nice feather in Kelly’s cap as underdogs in Chicago and a really fun win for a program that’s in a really happy place overall today.