It was ugly early on during the Notre Dame-Cal game on Saturday afternoon. And I mean very, very ugly. Nearly a full hour elapsed before a first down from either team was made. The Irish offense especially came out seriously disheveled with quarterback Drew Pyne playing like the moment was far too big for him. Look, it was dark for a while.

Things would get better. Both sides eventually started playing some competent football highlighted by Notre Dame playing up to its potential on both sides of the lines. The Irish got back to basics running the ball often and never forcing Pyne into any really difficult throws as the defense stepped up to slow California just enough for the win.

Stats Package
STAT IRISH BEARS
Score 24 17
Plays 64 68
Total Yards 297 296
Yards Per Play 4.64 4.35
Conversions 3/12 5/18
Completions 17 16
Yards/Pass Attempt 6.52 4.97
Rushes 41 31
Rushing Success 48.7% 45.8%
10+ Yds Rushes 3 8
20+ Yds Passes 2 1
Defense Stuff Rate 26.4% 21.8%

 

It was a big sigh of relief for Marcus Freeman who has been going through all of the emotions on the sidelines and should be glad to pick up his first victory at Notre Dame. At least the team showed some base competency in a lot of areas on Saturday. It’s something to build on but this team is far from out of the woods and will have to fight hard for a bowl game.

Offense

QB: C-
RB: B
TE: B+
OL: B
WR: ?

The game started so poorly for the offense that it had the strange feeling of knowing something so rank and absurd simply could not last. Despite the punt fest, the 1st quarter also dragged on for a long time too, extending the pain. Through Notre Dame’s first 5 drives the offense ran 14 plays for 16 yards. Five drives in a quarter for 16 yards!

That wonderful streak ended with a Drew Pyne fumbled snap leading to a short field and 1 of California’s 2 touchdowns in the game.

To start, Pyne looked rattled, nervous, and entirely too tense. That’s why I reflect on a performance that had nowhere to go but up, it was that bad without throwing a boat load of interceptions. Luckily, the Irish found a little bit of success on the ground and eventually got Pyne into a rhythm being the ultimate game manager.

To his credit, Pyne didn’t fold and finished the game completing 13 out of his last 14 passes. Now, I don’t think any of those attempts went further than 8 yards downfield outside of the Tyree touchdown pass but still!

The best news of the game was Notre Dame’s offensive line finally playing pretty well. California had a couple sacks but Pyne was largely comfortable in the pocket and the pass protection held up. Even better, the Irish found a serviceable run game. While the numbers aren’t great by any means (39 carries for 152 yards with sacks removed) it felt like a more impressive effort knowing Notre Dame wasn’t going to be doing a ton through the air–and California knew it too.

The calls to give the ball more to Chris Tyree were answered, while Logan Diggs was relegated to the bench. Tyree finished with 66 rushing yards and caught all 5 passes thrown his way while leading the team in receiving, including that vertical route out of the backfield finishing in a touchdown. Audric Estime also played well with a game-high 9 successful carries.

Rushing Success

Tyree – 8 of 17 (47.0%)
Estime – 9 of 18 (50.0%)
Pyne – 2 of 4 (50.0%)

Can we judge the receivers? They finished with a combined 10 targets for 7 receptions and 53 yards. There really wasn’t much of an attempt to make big plays through the air with everything extremely safe and meant to do no self-inflicting damage.

Notre Dame faced 12 opportunities on 3rd down and only threw the ball 7 times, converting only twice among completions of 6, 5, 6, and 1 yard. Dink and dunk.

Defense

DL: B+
LB: D
DB: C+

I’m usually one to nitpick what in recent years has been a strong Notre Dame defense. They’ve had their struggles this season, however, I thought this was a very good performance overall.

If the Irish offense was at least average I’m sure this would’ve been a comfortable win based on the play from the defense. For one, Cal’s running game was stifled all day. Running backs Jaydn Ott and DeCarlos Brooks had long runs of 13 and 24 yards respectively, but just 39 yards on their other 17 carries for 2.2 yards per rush.

Notre Dame really just needs to clean up some of the longer runs allowed (8 runs of 10+ yards is not cool) and I’d point the finger at the linebackers for that lack of success. Shockingly, quarterback Jack Plummer led California with 6 successful carries and his legs were a huge part in keeping the Golden Bears offense moving down field. Plummer had the sneak for a touchdown, plus 5 other carries go for a combined 80 yards! I’m not even mad I’m impressed.

Stuffs vs. California

Lacey – 3
Cross – 2.5
Ademilola, Jay – 2.5
Foskey – 2
Bertrand – 1.5
Ademilola, Jus. – 1.5
Brown – 1.5
Griffith – 1
Bracy – 0.5
Hart – 0.5
Smith – 0.5
Liufau – 0.5

The Irish defensive line came to play and won the day. They constantly harassed Plummer and didn’t allow him much time to deliver the ball down field. Any time you can get 6 sacks it’s been a good day in the office.

Something appears broken or not working with these linebackers. They are largely invisible. The only exception to that would be JD Bertrand’s insanely stupid targeting penalty to extend California’s final drive in what could’ve been one of the biggest boneheaded mistakes leading to a loss. Can you even imagine?

Here’s a summary of the top 4 Notre Dame linebackers against California:

0 solo tackles
0.5 tackles for loss
0 passes defended
2 combined stuffs

I mentioned in the pre-season that this group really needed Liufau to become a difference maker and that is a million miles away right now. Through 3 games, Liufau has 1 solo tackle, 0.5 tackles for loss, and no sacks.

The secondary played a well-rounded game but with a few too many mistakes. A coverage bust led to California’s far-too-easy first touchdown. A personal foul penalty on DJ Brown prevented a 3rd and long opportunity on California’s other touchdown drive. And, safety Brandon Joseph got way, way, way too greedy trying to intercept the final Hail Mary attempt and nearly costing the game had Jeremiah Hunter held on to the ball in his lap.

Final Thoughts

Watching Lenzy false start on a successful QB sneak on 3rd down–especially in a game like this where confidence and moving the chains was so important early–is one of those plays where there are no words.

On the Jacob Lacey sack in the 1st quarter, defensive end NaNa Osafo-Mensah was pancaked so hard he literally went flying several yards in the air. All’s well that ends well, though.

If Notre Dame doesn’t run for 200 yards in any game the rest of the season what do you think the final record will be? This was a peformance to be expected by Drew Pyne but eventually the passing game will have to open up. Things might be fine next week against the sieve North Carolina defense. After that, it’s going to be tough even with improved offensive line play.

It seems like Notre Dame is blitzing their middle linebackers an inordinate amount of the time. It isn’t working. For example, here’s California’s 2nd longest pass of the game and both Bertrand and Liufau end up on the ground making zero impact on the play.

There has to be a better way. 

All 6 sacks came from defensive linemen. Al Washington would like a word.

Tobias Merriweather got a few snaps, at least it’s a start of something.

The green jerseys looked magnificent in the afternoon sun. So many times it looked like a throwback to the late 1970’s out there. We’ve seen these jerseys at night under the lights and I think there’s something funky about that system that makes colors in general look really distorted, at least on television. They need white numbers ASAP. But, the blue lettering has been a school-wide decision for all sports for several years now.

When you saw Pyne throw that little pass in the flat into the turf, be honest, did you think Notre Dame would win?

NBC continued the tradition from last week of bringing in 2 new alum’s from each school to broadcast from the sidelines. My big question is who is coming for the UNLV game? Greg Anthony?

What happened on this “offsides” call in favor of Notre Dame?

A phantom penalty. 

It’s possible this is a very different game if the Irish simply miss this field goal. On the next series, Cal picked up a field goal and this could’ve been a 10-0 game approaching halftime. Also, throw in the targeting penalty on a failed 3rd down Pyne throw, too. The Golden Bears have to be kicking themselves for that missed opportunity.

A bit of a weird move for Marcus Freeman not to wear any green on the sidelines.

The Irish had an interception and fumble return (TD, too!) called back and are still without a forced turnover in 3 games. Auburn is the only other Power 5 team to not have a turnover on defense so far.

I found it curious that the offense didn’t really do much checking at the line, or checking to the sidelines, or getting the ball in the run game to anyone outside of the running backs.

Notre Dame is -0.25 in yards per play differential this year with the offense averaging 4.81 YPP and the defense at 5.07 YPP. Unless something miraculously changes with the offense the differential probably isn’t going to get much higher than +0.5 YPP and that probably means several more losses are coming.

I hope Notre Dame comes out with nameplates on the white jerseys next week. We’re headed to Chapel Hill!