As we await the drama of Signing Day and the Gator Bowl it’s time to fire up another edition of Five Wide Fullbacks. Five questions, five answers. This week we are taking a look at next year’s Heisman race, an underrated Irish opponent for next fall, the future of NFL Draft picks from South Bend, grading the current Notre Dame assistants, and changes to the transfer portal.

1) Taking an early look at the 2023 schedule, which team jumps out as looking tougher than anticipated? 

It’s sneaky good Tennessee Tech!

I’m kidding. There are a few options to consider, though. Jeff Brohm heading back to Louisville could inject some life into their program quickly, although quarterback Malik Jefferson is off to the NFL. I guess we can think about Pitt if First Round Phil™ finally lives up to whatever weird hype was created at Boston College. Sam Hartman could stay at Wake Forest but even if he doesn’t Dave Clawson has been keeping the Deacons relevant and frisky in recent years.

Looking so far ahead, it has to be Duke and Mike Elko in Durham currently Doing Good Things™ with a 8-4 record. They were solid on both sides of the ball in 2022, too. I have no idea what kind of attrition they’ll experience but it’ll be a road game.

Elko looks like a machinist who rips cigs all day but the man can coach football. 

The placement of a game like this could be key, too. Right now weeks 3, 6, 7, 9, 11, and 12 are open to slot in 4 ACC teams without dates. That means Duke could come after each of the Ohio State, USC, or Clemson games.

2) Caleb Williams won USC’s 8th Heisman Trophy (if you count the Reggie Bush hardware) over the weekend and it’ll be a long off-season of the Trojans quarterback going back-to-back talk. Who will challenge this cursing fingernail painter?

I’ve narrowed the list down to a top 12 of only quarterbacks. You could also make a case for the guys who end up starting at LSU, TCU, Oregon, UCLA, Georgia, and maybe even the plucky Fighting Irish.

Connor Weigman, Texas A&M – The Aggies offense has been abysmal but is going through a major off-season overhaul. Weigman was highly touted and had some bright moments in 2022. It’s not the worst long bet.

Dillon Gabriel, Oklahoma – This is only possible if the Sooners can turn things around quickly after a shockingly poor 2022. Gabriel also needs to stay healthy. If he does, the numbers will be there.

Drew Allar, Penn State – I’m going to throw Allar’s name in the hat because he has a very good skill-set and we could see PSU’s offense open up with him behind center. Accuracy could be an issue.

Joe Milton, Tennessee – If you’re a believer in the Josh Heupel offensive system here’s a good pick.

Jalen Milroe, Alabama – The passing game is going to be a work in the process. Milroe could be an instant 1000-yard rusher, think of something similar in style to Jalen Hurts.

Cade Klubnik, Clemson – It feels like Klubnik gained more experience in 2022 than just his 46 passing attempts. If he plays well in the bowl game look out for lots of Heisman talk.

Jordan Travis, Florida State – He didn’t even start his career with the Seminoles and yet it feels like Travis has been at Florida State since 2016. He’s a nice dual-threat option capable of 3,500 total yards next year.

Drake Maye, North Carolina – He’s losing his offensive coordinator, and maybe more importantly, receiver Josh Downs is off to the NFL. Plus, this is about team success–Maye put up monster numbers and only finished 10th in the 2022 Heisman voting.

Michael Penix, Washington – Here’s someone who finished 8th in the voting this year and also put up huge numbers. Can Washington win the Pac-12 and usurp USC because that’s what it would probably take for Penix to win in 2023.

Kyle McCord (or Devin Brown), Ohio State – I’m not sure what the outcome of this off-season competition is going to look like (assuming Stroud leaves for the NFL). It’s always a good bet to put some money on the Ohio State quarterback.

J.J. McCarthy, Michigan – Hate to even type it.

Quinn Ewers, Texas – Only if Texas is Back, though.

3) Notre Dame should have a fun NFL Draft this spring with Michael Mayer and Isaiah Foskey picking up headlines and hopefully being picked extremely high. What does the 2024-25 NFL talent pool look like for Notre Dame?

This is a fun and humbling exercise. It’s wild that people do this for all of college football because trying to predict this with accuracy for one program that I follow 24/7 is really hard. Here’s my guess for those drafts years:

2024
Joe Alt, 1st round
Cam Hart, 5th round
Howard Cross, 7th round

2025
Blake Fisher, 2nd round
Benjamin Morrison, 2nd round
Mitchell Evans, 4th round
Audric Estime, 5th round
Xavier Watts, 6th round

I tried to be as realistic as possible without projecting someone to make a big jump–well except for Xavier Watts. He’s a pick for someone who could play really well over the next 2 seasons. Someone like Rylie Milss has the NFL body to be scouted really hard in the coming years, although his development hasn’t progressed that much.

I was wondering if Alt will leave next year that has to be the record for the quickest, most awesome career in Irish history. If he does, I’m curious if they’ll move Fisher over to left tackle for a season of NFL auditioning.

4) How can we save college football by fixing the transfer portal? Can you name a new rule that the NCAA should implement in order to calm down situations like the current environment where we’ve gone from fewer than 900 transfers in 2020 to maybe over 3,000 this off-season?

I’ve been thinking about this and part of me likes making true freshmen wait 2 years if they want a free transfer. Either you transfer after your freshman season, sit out your sophomore season, and play again as a junior. Or, you stay your freshman and sophomore seasons then transfer immediately to a new school.

It got me wondering, could we see a portal based on snap counts?

For example, if you play at least 300 snaps during a season you cannot transfer with immediate eligibility. To me, this is a good way of decreasing the amount of really good players who are transferring to chase a ring or a larger NIL bag. It doesn’t seem fair or necessarily a good decision for a player who is making a decent to large contribution to his team and then go play somewhere else right away.

That gets a little more complicated for graduate transfers. Should they get free transfers no matter what? Look at J.T. Daniels. He’s leaving West Virginia and will be playing at his 4th school in 2023. He could even get a waiver and play at a 5th school in 2024. Is it really necessary to be leaving schools like this when you’re starting?

In general, I think I’m okay with players who don’t see the field, especially underclassmen, being able to transfer without having to sit. That would mirror a lot of the similarities with the general student body, too. But a 2-year wait could be helpful.

5) This was an important year for Marcus Freeman bringing in so many new assistants in his 1st season with the Irish. Can you hand out grades for each of the 2022 assistants and do you see Notre Dame moving on from any of them this off-season?

I’ll publish my grades first from best to worst before discussing any changes after the bowl game:

Brian Mason (Special Teams): A

The kick return team was a waste of time. Other than that, what a great season! Even the placekicking felt like it struggled for a long time but Grupe hit 72.2% of his field goals. We’ll talk about all the punt blocks for years to come.

Gerad Parker (Tight Ends): A

Maybe the easiest position to coach on the team, if we’re grading on a curve could you lower this? I would find it difficult. Parker got 2 true freshmen ready to play, brought Evans back from injury, and coached the Mackey winner.*

*We should act like Mayer won the award.

Mike Mickens (Cornerbacks): B+

There was a time in the off-season where corner was looking a bit scary if there was an injury or Clarence Lewis was forever riding the struggle bus. Well, there were some late-season injuries and Mickens did a really good job developing this unit. Obviously, the freshman All-American season for Morrison sticks out. Jaden Mickey had his ups and downs but could’ve developed more without injury. Plus, Hart and Bracy all got hurt and missed games.

Harry Hiestand (Offensive Line): B+

This unit improved greatly as the year wore on. I originally had a grade of B here but decided to bump it up. Still, this unit had the most clay to work with and those early season struggles (as well as the Navy game on the ground) leave us with a lot of “what if” questions.

Tommy Rees (Offensive Coordinator/Quarterbacks): B

Deep breath, okay here we go. I’m basing about 60% of this grade on QB development where I think Rees got just about as much out of Pyne as humanly possible and it was a tough hand dealt to him to pivot to a backup quarterback with an iffy wide receiver corps.

Anyone getting fired?

Still, there were some dark moments for this offense but 42nd in FEI isn’t that bad with Pyne? I would guess at least half of Irish fans would have a lower grade here, though.

Deland McCullough (Running Backs): B

This unit mostly had a good year. Although, oddly every tailback went through a slump and had some tough moments. You have to wonder what 2022 looked like with a healthy Jadarian Price.

Chansi Stuckey (Wide Receiver): B

I struggled the most with this grade. The offense basically developed no true number one receiver as Lorenzo Styles really struggled with drops and an inability to make plays. We also saw Lenzy be mostly a body for the vast majority of the season. However, the development of Jayden Thomas and Deion Colzie were bright spots. Merriweather was making slow progress until his injury issues, too.

Chris O’Leary (Safeties): C+

This group just didn’t seem to put it together or be impactful enough over the course of the season. Brandon Joseph was supposed to be a big time playmaker and that never transpired. That missing piece really colors this grade. Some younger guys like Watts and Henderson trending up is cause for optimism next season. You would’ve liked more out of a veteran Joseph/Brown/Griffith group.

Al Washington (Defensive Line): C

Who was the 2nd best defensive lineman this season? It’s a tough question! I would probably pick Howard Cross. This unit played well for long stretches, I won’t deny that. It was also a group that was supposed to be incredibly deep and I’m not sure we saw a few players’ jump up and turn heads like some expected. It felt like a lot of guys, even if they played well, flat lined.

Al Golden (Defensive Coordinator/Linebackers): D

This is going to feel harsh. The defense only gave up over 400 yards once (USC) all season. They kept 9 teams under 30 points. In 3 out of the 4 losses it was the defense keeping the team in the game. It still felt like a let down. The 5.17 YPP is fine but many of the traditional stats are boosted by a slow offense driving down possessions. They only forced 13 turnovers in 12 games, and 8 in 11 games outside the hapless BC offense. The red zone touchdown percentage was 2nd worse nationally. In particular, the play of the linebackers was a big disappointment and frankly pretty bizarre at times.

If I had told you pre-season that the Irish defense would stay quite healthy on defense but fall 20 spots to 31st in FEI (the lowest ranking since 2015) just 11 spots better than the offense, with all the problems at linebacker, what would your grade be?

***

I doubt anyone will be fired. We’ve discussed at length that Rees could leave for another job somewhere, which is still possible. I think I’m guilty of seeing positives while giving the offense a pass for not having enough talent (QB & WR) and the assistants coaching them up pretty well. Others will think, “We should be at a certain championship level, we’re not, the grade is D.”

My three lowest grades were all reserved for defense where my expectations were higher and I don’t think they were met in many instances. I wouldn’t be shocked if Washington or Golden were let go but I don’t see it happening. Either way, they have to figure some things out with the linebackers and Washington has a huge year coming up in a post-Foskey world.