Despite the efforts of far more than 11 people on the field in the second half, Notre Dame kept SMU out of the end zone for all 60 minutes Saturday night and dispatched SMU 24-3, leaving just one more win between the Irish and what will almost certainly be a home game in the College Football Playoff.

It was far from the cleanest game for the Irish, which dealt with a couple of early stupid occurrences that gave this fan base brief flashes of the last Saturday filled with top-10 upsets (which ended with ND’s loss to BYU). Luckily, no such wackiness ensued in South Bend.

A defense that seems to have to dodge a new haymaker every week warded off the injury departure of Luke Talich (that he was instantly ruled out for the game strikes me as a very bad sign for his chances of playing again this season) still dominated the Mustangs and bailed out an offense seemingly determined to test them in every way they could.

Let’s take a look at a few of the standout storylines of the latest Irish win:

The defense is pretty much hitting on all cylinders

Whatever happened at the half against Navy on Halloween, the Notre Dame defense continues to look like a reborn unit ever since. They took a few punches. An early huge run by SMU (Leonard Moore racing what must have been 80-plus yards in all to save a touchdown should lead every one of his highlight reels) put ND behind the 8-ball, but the Irish delivered a stop anyway. Christian Gray, who spiritually should have played for Pat Narduzzi’s defense at Michigan State, learned that sometimes they actually can call you for interference if you’re always committing interference, but the Irish delivered a stop anyway. The ACC officials all but started inventing penalties in an effort to get SMU a consolation touchdown after not calling for holding a single time in the game – for reasons only they can tell us – but the Irish delivered a stop anyway.

The story all offseason was that if ND was to be a true national title contender, their defense was going to likely be the biggest reason why. They are, and they are. The Irish know who they are on defense now – why it took so long, who knows – and they’re a unit that’s going to be a pill for anyone. Jayden Sanders will be just fine as CB1 next season after Leonard Moore goes pro, thank you. Kyngstonn Viliamu-Asa is and will continue to be a holy terror. Boubacar Traore might be Captain America for all we know – he is everywhere on the defensive end.

The ND offense couldn’t one-up Wake Forest’s explosive performance against SMU last week, but the ND defense certainly did. A hobbled Kevin Jennings averaged under five yards per pass attempt and was basically hopeless against a relentless Irish rush, and outside of the one big burst to start the game, SMU’s running game was all but wiped out.

Nolan James

He’s got at least one more year left at Notre Dame and I can already tell Nolan James is going to be the sort of player everyone likes but not nearly enough people love. Did you even know he has scored a touchdown in every game this season? I didn’t until it was brought up during the Miami game, and he indeed has exactly one score in every 2026 contest.

He ran for 98 yards today, gained six yards per attempt, and has a remarkable knack for always getting the number of yards the team needs him to get. He is never going to be Jeremiyah Love, but he is one hell of a versatile, tough athlete. (The guy flat-out does not go down on first contact, and even if the first guy gets him, he almost always seems to get another couple of yards out of it.) Notre Dame is fortunate that he is going to be RB1 in 2027 as well as the rest of this season.

By the way, another shout to the offensive line for opening big holes for James and again protecting CJ Carr, who, time for the downer part of the wrap-up:

CJ Carr will need to be far better than this

The nice thing about criticizing CJ Carr in this space is that we know enough about him to know no one will think he played worse today than he does. I fully expect him to throw this one in the garbage and deliver a better performance next week and beyond.

And it’s a good thing he will, because for all his numbers – he ended up with 312 passing yards, but only 70 after halftime – he was pretty lousy in this game. Not BYU-level lousy, but he missed a few makeable throws, threw a terrible interception (Jordan Faison broke wide open basically as Carr was looking away from him) and just didn’t quite seem like himself. Luckily, Carr should have another game at Notre Dame Stadium left in his career and will have a chance to make a better lasting memory before (we think) heading to the pros.

By the way, let’s be real: The worst of Carr is still pretty solid. Lock on Faison another half-second – and even despite his early fumble, why wouldn’t you? – and Carr ends the night without a turnover and probably about 350 yards. Carr was also on the delivery end of the biggest highlight reel play of the night:

Injuries and the big picture

It was great to see Charles Jagusah take the field for the Irish. Unbelievably, he had never taken the field at Notre Dame Stadium before tonight. It seems hard to believe he’s at a form that would allow him to unseat anyone on an Irish line that might be the best position group ND has as we move forward, but we’ve been wrong about him before.

Jaden Greathouse made one excellent play to help spearhead ND’s 99-yard touchdown drive and then left the game with a wrist/hand injury. Please be ok for the playoff, Jaden.

Brauntae Johnson did not take the field in this game, but coach Marcus Freeman (who just clinched his fourth straight 10-win season) said he was close. With Talich likely shelved for the postseason, Johnson’s return will be sorely needed, although credit to 5-star freshman Joey O’Brien for a very solid game that should build confidence in him to take a bigger role next season.

Next week, ND travels to Syracuse (it remains very stupid that ND will finish a regular season in upstate New York, thanks again Lincoln Riley) and unfortunately may again not get to play against old friend Steve Angeli, who was injured in today’s game. A win will extend the season another 3 weeks. Let’s get a win.

(Photo credit – South Bend Tribune)