It’s one of Notre Dame nation’s favorite words when delivered by Marcus Freeman: Violence. And the second I heard it come out of his mouth in the pregame interview today, all concerns about Rice being the next horror story chapter in the “second game of a Marcus Freeman season” book basically went out the window.
And the Irish defense took it to heart, blasting Rice players left and right in the early parts of the game, including one Adon Shuler hit that forced a fumble-six and set the tone for a 52-0 shutout.
Boubacar understood the assignment 🙂↕️#GoIrish☘️ | @24era24
📺: NBC pic.twitter.com/cWP4NjImtl
— Notre Dame Football (@NDFootball) September 12, 2026
It was not the game that will provide any particular lasting memories of the 2026 season, but it was a nice reminder that for this team, it looks like “Leave No Doubt” was more than just a buzzword.
A few takeaways from the Irish’s move to 2-0:
This defense plays like they know exactly how good they are
Ever since Freeman showed up and taking recruiting to a different level, much of that success has been on the defensive side of the ball. His defenses have, with one very notable 2.5-game blip in early 2025, gotten better and better and better as the talent has poured in. Two games in, this group looks every bit the successor to that mantle.
The Irish starters didn’t allow Rice’s triple option to have any success at all (a good sign for the Halloween game against Navy). Especially early on, the poor Owl ball carriers seemed like they were being used for (non-flag version, despite what Rice coach Scott Abell pleaded for) target practice by the front seven and by Adon Shuler. Shuler, who was already one of the harder hitters in the country a year ago, now is playing as if he would dearly love to see every offensive opponent have deep chest bruises for a week after going up against him.
It was also very pleasant to see Kyngstonn Viliamu-Asa back on the field and looking exactly like we hoped he would, and the front four enjoyed another rock-solid performance, getting consistent push into the backfield against the overmatched Rice offensive line.
CJ Carr spread the ball around as much as he could
When it comes down to it, CJ Carr is going to throw to Jordan Faison. It’s a bit reminiscent of 2012, when everyone on the field knew Notre Dame was going to toss it up to Tyler Eifert every big third down and yet it was still rarely stopped. Such is the connection between Carr and Faison, who remains one of the more underrated players in the country.
However, Carr – and later, Noah Grubbs – got others involved as well. It was nice to see Jaden Greathouse look a bit like the guy we remember, particularly on a very contested back-shoulder throw along the sidelines. And as picture-perfect a throw as Carr delivered to Micah Gilbert for a late first-half touchdown, it was just as impressive a catch by the third-year wideout, who continues to make his presence felt.
.@13Cjcarr x @Gilbert316Micah = 👨🍳🤌#GoIrish☘️
📺: NBC pic.twitter.com/RMcnaCevcV
— Notre Dame Football (@NDFootball) September 12, 2026
A glance at the future
The huge early lead allowed Irish fans to take a look at some of the names we assume we’ll see take on bigger roles in 2027. Of the group, I doubt I’ll find much disagreement in being most impressed with freshman Jonaz Walton. I’m not going to overstate the run he made on 4th and short by dipsy-dooing around an unblocked rusher and beating the rest of the Rice defenders to the edge, because it was Rice. But still, between that and his bruising running style he showed off later, it’s easy to look at him and think he’s going to be The Guy sooner or later in that backfield.
Walton’s size, build and running style bears more than a passing resemblance, to me, to Jadarian Price. He’s exciting.
We also got some nice looks at Logan Saldate and three of the NFL progeny wideouts – Jerome Bettis Jr., Devin Fitzgerald and Elijah Burress. Matt Jeffery’s contributions weren’t unnoticed, either.
OK, now we concern-troll
Was it maybe a bit concerning that the offensive line was unable to create a ton of running lanes for Aneyas Williams and company early in the game? Hard to critique the pass blocking on a day Carr seemed to have all day whenever he wanted, but it did feel as though Williams struggled to get into a groove. Nolan James, too, for that matter, though he still ripped off a couple nice ones.
I would rate this very low on the concern scale – after all, we just saw the line struggle early against Wisconsin and then put it together. And Guerby Lambert left the game at one point – no word on his status, though he only left with a slight limp. So that was likely a factor. But still, we’re fans and we have to at least feign concern about something.
Next week is Michigan State. It probably won’t be as easy as this. With a night game at ND and a presumably charged up crowd ready to renew an old rivalry, the hope is ND brings the thunder the way they did early on today.
(Photo credit – South Bend Tribune)
Merci for the fast and well-phrased review, Andy. It’s a pleasure to read analyses by folks one trusts who always bring informed perspectives. To this game, I absolutely loved seeing CJ spread the ball literally to every single WR and in a way that IMO will contribute to their growth, individually and collectively. Thereby addressing the widespread concern over this issue from last week.
Related to widespread fanbase wringing of hands, I see over on our Discord channels that some of the comments are echoing your concerns over the running game. I am thinking myself that our O-line has kind of a tradition of gelling later in the season — and in this case, our RBs and TEs seem to be in the same mode. So I’m of the opinion that we our schedule for the first 6 games could truly be a blessing — and given HCMF’s clearly deeply felt mantra about focusing on the now and making incremental progress, I’m guardedly optimistic. What say you?
Couldn’t agree more on the last few sentences – Freeman teams have always improved significantly as the season goes along, and for whatever minor flaws this group still has, if this is where we’re improving from, the rest of the country is in deep trouble.
I agree that the OLine, especially the right side will get better. Post game I’ve heard a few comments that Williams was feeling the effects of the Wisc. game. That could be but, that’s concerning too. Is he cut out to be a #1 ? Most likely we are going to get a much better feel on things next Saturday. MSU should be a better test for the run game and WRs. If there hasn’t been standouts at WR (Faison excepted) and RB, there are plenty of candidates at both positions that could be an answer. We have the answers on defense (what depth!) and at QB, Wow, great performance boys. Great to see KVA back and CJ has as good a grasp of the offense as can be.
I think we are very strong across the board. Our defense alone should keep is in every game.
If we want to beat Miami and make a run in the playoffs, I think we’ll need to find more playmakers on offense. As Noise mentioned, we have half a season to figure it out, so I’m not too worried yet.
Also: Carr looks like the real deal.
I wonder if Denbrock will start getting some specific packages together for the young receivers. Let Bubba Frazier learn 15 plays and try to burn defenses with those. Get Devin Fitzgerald on the field in jumbo/goal line packages. Get Burress opportunities to get the ball in space on screens/jet sweeps.
It seems like there are some guys who could bring some explosiveness but simply might not be ready to be “the guy” yet. I thought Burress looked like the best athlete on the field at times, but was a little too hyperactive trying to get things going. The more he plays, the more I could see him becoming a real problem against man coverage.
Good original idea on the packages for the young WRs. If any QB could make that work, it’s CJ.
The coaches might be prioritizing well-rounded players/more experience for now. I saw CMF likes the new eligibility rules because it lets them experiment more.
Need an updated ND All-Time player ranking after this season; Shuler has to be somewhere in an upper tier I would think. Dude doesn’t ever get beaten in the passing game and hits like a linebacker, while rarely missing a tackle. I know a running back catching a pass in the flat hates to see him coming.
Carr made some of those throws (that he didn’t need to make against Wisconsin) that really showcase his potential to be the first QB taken next year. The throw to Greathouse was the most perfectly thrown back shoulder ball I’ve seen an ND QB throw in a long time. (Grubbs also looked better than I thought he would, so that was a nice reassurance; pretty sure we could beat any team in the schedule other than Miami with him playing the whole game).
I’m at the point where I would rather see Nolan James get carries over Aneyas. I have so much confidence in Carr converting 3rd and short/medium passing, so when we run the ball, I would rather give it to the guy who has more explosive upside (perhaps that could even be Walton sooner rather than later). Play Aneyas on 3rd down/obvious passing downs and let him be Theo Riddick.
Amen on the back shoulder to Jaden G. Very good catch as well. Good sign.
On the RBs, not to forget pass pro. In any case, the coaches have been intimating for months that it’ll be RB by committee, and I see more good news than bad news here.
Keeping CJ clean needs to be the #1 priority.
“Protect CJ Carr” is second only to “Leave No Doubt.” Grubbs looked competent (we didn’t get to see much of Jarrard), but it’s very obvious this team’s ambitions go up in smoke if CJ isn’t out there.
Interesting, in that CJ is smart enough to know that. Not gonna be Jaxson Dart his rookie year. There’s been much made over his insatiable desire to get to really know O-line play and what they’re looking at (or should be looking at), but one or two of those coach/player quotes made what I thought were explicit links to pass pro. Nor do I expect to see much QB run?
The backups looked comfortable but against a defense that had been throttled for 35+ minutes. How they would look vs a better defense designed to confuse them, might be a whole different story. I don’t want to know the answer to that query.
Did I hear correctly that Cam Williams didn’t log a snap against Rice? Safe to say he’ll never do anything meaningful at ND?